• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Name Industry News

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Submit News
  • Comment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise Hosting & Domain Industry Jobs
You are here: Home / registries / What is .art Playing at?

What is .art Playing at?

January 5, 2021 by Michele Neylon

When new TLDs were being introduced one of the arguments in their favour is that they’d offer more choices to registrants.

Earlier today the .art registry made a rather odd announcement:

.ART third-level domains are here! What is a third-level domain? Why choosing one? Read more about on our blog & get started on your online presence! https://t.co/Sz6YDd6CS9#artdomains #.art #domains #thirdlevel pic.twitter.com/7ie94iCwJz

— .art Domains (@Art_Domains) January 5, 2021

Apparently they’re now offering “3rd level domains”

What now?

According to the blog post:

ART’s third-level domains provide an inexpensive and easy-to-use entrée into the world of domain names.They also have key advantages:

Get a low-cost, introductory opportunity to establish your unique & permanent online address;
Showcase your project, hobby or collections;
Protect your intellectual property in a way that other online platforms do not;
Third-level domains are exempt from renewal fees. You only pay once!

There’s no indication of how much these “domains” would cost, whether there’s any intellectual property protections for existing IP holders or any other details. The claim about intellectual property protection is bizarre, as not only are these not proper domain names, but the .art registry itself is already offering domains for sale like nokia.art (Nokia take a fairly dim view of domains being registered using their marks)

Basically the idea behind 3rd level names is to create namespaces from existing domains. Technically they aren’t “real” domain names at all and are just subdomains of existing domain names.

Unless, of course, the registry is setup to support them fully.

Which in theory, at least, Centralnic, who run the .art backend, would be. Centralnic did after all cut its teeth selling domain names based off “extensions” like gb.com

There’s no issue with a registrant setting up their domain(s) for 3rd level registrations, though some registry operators might explicitly forbid it. When you signup for some online services you are automatically given a subdomain eg. $username.$service.$tld

However in the new TLD space a registry would need to get sign off from ICANN if they wanted to offer 3rd level registrations. ICANN has a process for this called the “Registry Services Evaluation Policy” which is how domain name registries add, change or remove extra services like registry lock, IDN support and others.

You can peruse the archives of RSEP requests here.

There’s been quite a few over the years, but not all of them have been granted. Why? Well in some cases there are technical or policy reasons why the introduction of a “service” could be seen as problematic.

In the case of 3rd level registrations the only domain name registry to have submitted a request to offer this kind of service was the now defunct operator of the .wed domain registry. They put in a request to dish out 3rd level domain names using a rather large number of domains – over 11 thousand – which was rejected by ICANN.

In the case of .art there’s no trace of any RSEP for this, so what are they playing at?

As the registry operator for .art they are bound by the contract and policies, so offering the 3rd level domains would require formal approval.

Breaching the contract could cause them headaches, as ultimately ICANN has the power to decide who, if anyone, operates a specific top level domain extension.

Filed Under: icann, registries Tagged With: art, centralnic, icann, rsep

About Michele Neylon

Michele is founder and managing director of Irish domain registrar and hosting company Blacknight. Michele has been deeply involved in domain and internet policy discussions for more than a decade.
He also co-hosts the Technology.ie podcast.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

ICANN’s Cancún Meeting Was Almost Normal

Middle East DNS Forum to be Held in Istanbul

Gandi Merges with TWS to Form “Your.Online”

Anguilla Offline due to Fibre Issue

IGF 2023 to be Held in Kyoto, Japan

Recent Comments

  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement
  • Kieren McCarthy Elected to Nominet Board on Nominet Election Candidates 2022 Finally Announced
  • Michele Neylon on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • Gavin Brown on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • ICANN Heading to Hamburg (ICANN78) and Los Angeles (GDD) Plus Training For African Registries - Goldstein Report on ICANN Announces GDD Summit Dates & Location

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Archives

Recent Comments

  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement
  • Kieren McCarthy Elected to Nominet Board on Nominet Election Candidates 2022 Finally Announced
  • Michele Neylon on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • Gavin Brown on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • ICANN Heading to Hamburg (ICANN78) and Los Angeles (GDD) Plus Training For African Registries - Goldstein Report on ICANN Announces GDD Summit Dates & Location

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson
  • Nigel Roberts

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Copyright © 2023 InternetNews.me