• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Name Industry News

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Submit News
  • Comment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
You are here: Home / icann / The Battle Over Whois Policy Continues

The Battle Over Whois Policy Continues

August 22, 2007 by Michele Neylon

ICANN Logo

One of the sessions I attended at the ICANN meeting in Lisbon earlier this year centred on whois. It became abundantly clear to me that the various stakeholders had very different views and objectives on how to treat and publish registrant data.

I wouldn’t care to get into the finer points of the arguments, as the parties involved have done so time and again without reaching an acceptable compromise or agreement.

Milton Mueller’s article, “Whois Privacy Stalemate .. Again”, which was published on the Internet Governance Project site earlier today covers the situation and the various points of view in some detail.

For those of you who want a bluffer’s guide the issues can be split into two broad camps.

On the one side you have individuals and groups who are concerned about privacy issues. Under the current system anyone with access to a computer can glean quite a bit of information regarding a domain holder (registrant) by simply checking the WHOIS output. (There are a multitude of online services that facilitate this).

On the other side of the fence sit law enforcement and IP protection lawyers who want to be able to track down criminals and wrongdoers quickly and easily. If, for example, a domain is being used to run a scam or a phishing attack you might be able to get the site taken offline quickly, but ultimately it would be preferable to trackdown the person or persons behind it (of course it’s unlikely that the information they provided to register the domain is accurate, but that’s a completely different argument.

The whois debate has also spilled over into the current discussions surrounding the registrar accreditation agreement which I mentioned recently. While whois output may not be central to the RAA the treatment of registrants is, so it’s only natural that there would be some discussion. Of course there is a fine line between useful discussion and distracting debate.

Is there a solution? One would hope so, but finding one that marries all parties’ concerns into an acceptable compromise solution is not going to be easy.

Filed Under: icann, policy, privacy, registrants, registrars, trademark, whois Tagged With: icann, intellectual property, law, policy, privacy, trademark, whois

About Michele Neylon

Michele is founder and managing director of Irish domain registrar and hosting company Blacknight. Michele has been deeply involved in domain and internet policy discussions for more than a decade.
He also co-hosts the Technology.ie podcast.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

Nominet NED Nominations Open

ICANN Logo

ICANN Announces Locations for two Future Meetings

DNS Belgium logo

DNS Belgium Opens Call for Registrar Forum

ICANN Logo

ICANN 82 Seattle Full Schedule Available

RIPE Chair and Vice Chair Nominations Open

Recent Comments

  • Jim Davies Threatening Legal Action Against Nominet on Nominet Elections Candidates Announced
  • Paul on Nominet Elections Candidates Announced
  • Snail Mucin on Does the Epik Sale Signal the end of the Saga or just a new Chapter?
  • John Berryhill on Does the Epik Sale Signal the end of the Saga or just a new Chapter?
  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Archives

Recent Comments

  • Jim Davies Threatening Legal Action Against Nominet on Nominet Elections Candidates Announced
  • Paul on Nominet Elections Candidates Announced
  • Snail Mucin on Does the Epik Sale Signal the end of the Saga or just a new Chapter?
  • John Berryhill on Does the Epik Sale Signal the end of the Saga or just a new Chapter?
  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson
  • Nigel Roberts

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Copyright © 2025 InternetNews.me