• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Industry & Internet News

Domain Name Industry News

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Submit News
  • Comment Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise Hosting & Domain Industry Jobs
You are here: Home / iana / Why Won’t ICANN Answer Questions?

Why Won’t ICANN Answer Questions?

June 12, 2011 by Michele Neylon

Rod Beckstrom and Peter Dengate Thrush - Regis...
Image by blacknight via Flickr

During the last public ICANN meeting in San Francisco there was a public forum. This is quite normal.

Several people asked questions of the ICANN board, some were answered, others weren’t.

Why not?

Nigel Roberts from the Channel Isles registry asked the following (for the sake of clarity I’m republishing the entire section of the transcript):

>>NIGEL ROBERTS: Thank you, Peter. My name is Nigel Roberts. I
am with the Channel Islands registry. We run dot gg and dot je.

As there is currently an opportunity for the public to provide
input to the U.S. government regarding the IANA contract renewal, I
would like to take this opportunity here in the public forum to ask
what I think is a fundamental question for the record so that I and
others can decide what sort of input to make to the IANA contract
comment period.

In Article 4 of the ICANN Articles of Incorporation, ICANN bound
itself to relevant international law. In the case of ICM Registry
against ICANN, the review panel ruled it had legal effect in
California.

Now, as the performance of the IANA contract particularly as it
relates to Country Code Top Level Domains, literally, can have effect
in all sovereign nations and dependent territories in the world. I
wonder if you could please confirm something for me.

One of the benefits of age is that you lose distance vision.
Excuse me a second.

Would you confirm whether or not relevant international law
includes the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of 1949 and/or the
European Convention of Human Rights in 1950 either wholly or
partially? And if the answer is “partially,” which parts are not
relevant?

>>PETER DENGATE THRUSH: Nigel, I wonder if you can help me to
start so I can ask the correct people to address this. This is
obviously not an easy one to deal with on the fly.

Sorry. What part of the bylaws — what part of Article 4 were you
referring to at the very beginning?

>>NIGEL ROBERTS: To be precise, I’m referring to the comments in
ICM Registry against ICANN where it refers to Article 4 stating that
ICANN has bound itself to respect relevant principles of
international law.

>>PETER DENGATE THRUSH: All right. I think we are going to have
to spend some time thinking about exactly what you’re asking.

>>NIGEL ROBERTS: Happy to take an offline reply in writing.

>>PETER DENGATE THRUSH: Thanks. If we can get back to you before
the end of the public forum, so we can do it here, Nigel, we will.
We are not trying to hide from a very —

>>NIGEL ROBERTS: I realize it is not a question you can answer in
three seconds, but it is a question I would like an answer within a
reasonable time, if that’s okay.

>>PETER DENGATE THRUSH: Let’s take that under advisement, as
Americans say, and we will come back to you as soon as we can.

>>NIGEL ROBERTS: And if it will assist, I will provide the
question in writing.

>>PETER DENGATE THRUSH: That would help as well. Thanks.

So did he ever get a reply?

Apparently not. Three months later he’s still waiting for a reply.

I also asked a question in relation to IANA and did get a reply – of sorts.

If ICANN cannot answer questions from its stakeholders and community ie. those of us who go to meetings or have a contract with the Corporation, how can it be expected to “play nice” with the wider world?

Is it any surprise that relations between ICANN and governments are a bit “strained” at times?

Related articles
  • Questionable Impact for US Senate Hearing on New gTLDs (circleid.com)
  • ICANN Sets June Target for New gTLD Program Launch (circleid.com)

Filed Under: iana, icann Tagged With: ccTLDs, Country code top-level domain, European Convention of Human Rights, Generic top-level domain, iana, icann, Internet Assigned Numbers Authority, Peter Dengate Thrush, San Francisco, Top-level domain, transparency

About Michele Neylon

Michele is founder and managing director of Irish domain registrar and hosting company Blacknight. Michele has been deeply involved in domain and internet policy discussions for more than a decade.
He also co-hosts the Technology.ie podcast.

Primary Sidebar

Recent Articles

ICANN’s Cancún Meeting Was Almost Normal

Middle East DNS Forum to be Held in Istanbul

Gandi Merges with TWS to Form “Your.Online”

Anguilla Offline due to Fibre Issue

IGF 2023 to be Held in Kyoto, Japan

Recent Comments

  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement
  • Kieren McCarthy Elected to Nominet Board on Nominet Election Candidates 2022 Finally Announced
  • Michele Neylon on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • Gavin Brown on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • ICANN Heading to Hamburg (ICANN78) and Los Angeles (GDD) Plus Training For African Registries - Goldstein Report on ICANN Announces GDD Summit Dates & Location

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Archives

Recent Comments

  • ICANN Gets First Female CEO on Centralnic Head Honcho Announces Immediate Retirement
  • Kieren McCarthy Elected to Nominet Board on Nominet Election Candidates 2022 Finally Announced
  • Michele Neylon on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • Gavin Brown on Nominet Taking RDAP Out of Beta
  • ICANN Heading to Hamburg (ICANN78) and Los Angeles (GDD) Plus Training For African Registries - Goldstein Report on ICANN Announces GDD Summit Dates & Location

Categories

Blogroll

  • Alex Bligh
  • Circle ID
  • Domain Incite
  • Domain Name News
  • Domain Name Wire
  • Jason Thompson
  • Nigel Roberts

Blogs

  • Domain Gang
  • Stéphane Bortzmeyer

Copyright © 2023 InternetNews.me